England legend Geoffrey Boycott has issued a harsh but heartfelt rebuke to Test captain Ben Stokes, continuing the heated debate sparked by Stokes’ “has-beens” comment about former England players. With the second Ashes Test in Brisbane approaching, Boycott has made it clear that criticism from ex-cricketers comes from care—not contempt.
Stokes’ “Has-Beens” Remark Rekindles Old Tensions
England’s poor preparation for the Ashes — with just one warm-up game — triggered widespread criticism from former players.
Annoyed by those comments, Stokes responded by calling ex-cricketers “has-beens,” a remark he later admitted was a “horrible word” and a mistake.
But Boycott wasn’t satisfied with the apology.
“We don’t enjoy watching you embarrass yourselves and lose,” Boycott wrote in The Telegraph.
“We want England to win. We can’t praise bad cricket — that’s impossible.”
He stressed that criticism comes from wanting England to play better, not from bitterness or personal agendas.
“Play Better and Win” — Boycott’s Straightforward Message
Boycott pointed directly to the collapse in Perth, where England lost from a position of strength.
He argued that such defeats naturally draw strong reactions from the media and former players.
He added that England have adopted a siege mentality — acting as though the world is against them — when in reality, supporters and ex-players simply want results.
“England were certain their preparation was right. Fine — then prove it on the field.”
Concerns Over Bowling & Stokes’ Captaincy
Boycott also questioned England’s bowling strength and urged the batters to show more discipline and mental toughness.
On Stokes’ leadership, Boycott was sharp:
The skipper is known for creative tactics but must respond better when opponents, like Travis Head in Perth, attack England’s bowlers.
He suggested that innovation is good, but not when it replaces accountability.
“Learn From the Elders” — Boycott’s Cultural Advice
In a pointed but thoughtful remark, Boycott said Stokes must not dismiss the wisdom of former players simply because the game has evolved.
“In Asia, elders are respected for the knowledge they’ve gained. They offer counsel because they’ve lived it.”
Quoting Richie Benaud, he reminded Stokes:
“You can learn something every day.”
Boycott warned that stubbornness becomes a weakness when a leader refuses to listen to valuable insight.
“Has-Beens” Comment Was Disrespectful, Says Boycott
Boycott stressed that many of the ex-players Stokes casually dismissed as “has-beens” were part of Ashes-winning sides in both England and Australia — something the current squad has yet to achieve.
“None of this team has won the Ashes in Australia. Those ‘has-beens’ have.”
He concluded with a challenge:
“Win the Ashes. Then you won’t need to say anything. The glory will come to you.”
Stay updated with the latest Cricket News, Match Predictions, Fantasy Tips, and Live Cricket Action—only on Today Cricket Matches!